-
Francesco Redi
Francesco Redi (1626–1697) was an Italian physician, naturalist, and poet. He is often considered one of the founders of experimental biology. Redi challenged the idea of spontaneous generation with one of the first controlled experiments in scientific history. His meticulous work paved the way for the development of modern experimental techniques and helped introduce a scientific approach to biology. -
Redi’s experiment
In 1668, Redi tested spontaneous generation by placing meat in three jars: one open, one sealed, and one covered with a cloth net. Maggots appeared only in the open jar, proving they came from fly eggs, not the meat itself. Sealed and cloth-covered jars showed no maggots on the meat, though they formed on the cloth. This debunked spontaneous generation for visible organisms but didn’t rule it out for microorganisms, which were too small to observe at the time. -
John Needham
John Needham (1713–1781) was an English clergyman and naturalist. He conducted experiments to support spontaneous generation, a belief held by many during his time. Needham was fascinated by microorganisms, which were newly visible thanks to the invention of the microscope. His work, though flawed, played a role in the debate over the origins of life and inspired further research into microbiology. -
Lazzaro Spallanzani
Lazzaro Spallanzani (1729–1799) was an Italian priest and biologist. Known for his meticulous experiments, he sought to disprove spontaneous generation. He expanded on Needham’s work by refining experimental techniques to eliminate contamination. Spallanzani’s contributions to microbiology and sterilization laid the groundwork for future scientific advancements, including Pasteur’s work. -
Needham’s rebuttal
In 1745, Needham boiled broth briefly to kill microorganisms, then sealed the flasks. After a time, microorganisms reappeared, leading him to conclude that life could spontaneously arise. However, his experiment had flaws: insufficient boiling allowed heat-resistant microbes to survive, or sealing the flasks after cooling let airborne microbes enter. His results were later refuted but kept the debate alive. -
Criticism from Spallanzani
Spallanzani improved Needham’s experiment by sealing flasks of broth before boiling them for longer durations. No microorganisms appeared in sealed flasks, but once unsealed, microbial growth occurred. He concluded that microorganisms came from the air, not spontaneous generation. Critics argued he removed a "vital life force" by sealing flasks, but his work was pivotal in challenging spontaneous generation. -
Louis Pasteur
Louis Pasteur (1822–1895) was a French chemist and microbiologist celebrated for his discoveries in germ theory and fermentation. He ended the spontaneous generation debate through meticulous experiments and innovations, such as the swan-neck flask. His work revolutionized science, leading to advances in microbiology, vaccines, and public health. Pasteur's famous motto, "Life only comes from life," remains a cornerstone of biology. -
Pasteur puts spontaneous generation to rest
Pasteur’s 1864 experiment used swan-neck flasks filled with boiled broth. The flask’s curved neck allowed air to enter but trapped dust and microbes. No microbial growth occurred in undisturbed flasks for a year, but when the neck was broken or tilted, growth appeared. Pasteur proved microorganisms came from airborne particles, not spontaneous generation. His work conclusively ended this centuries-old debate.